Mackinac Island Creamery
Your Favorite Line of Premium Ice Cream
In 2001, after years of developing award-winning flavors for other companies, we decided to produce our own line of ice cream to sell to ice cream parlors and restaurants across the Midwest. Today, we proudly offer 30 outstanding flavors.
Our Current Flavors
Peanut Butter Pie
Sumptuous cheesecake ice cream with sweet golden graham cracker swirl and overflowing with juicy strawberries
Tawas Bay Lemon Cheesecake
Mouth-watering lemon cheesecake ice cream brimming with golden graham variegate
Creamy peanut butter swirling through rich chocolate ice cream filled with chocolate covered peanut butter buckeyes.
The simple elegance of pure vanilla ice cream
Black Fox Cookies & Cream
Exquisite full-bodied vanilla ice cream bursting with dark chocolate cream cookies.
Black Swamp Raspberry
Delicious Raspberry Cheesecake ice cream swirled with Mackinac chocolate graham crust and teaming with chocolate black raspberry filled cups.
Georgian Bay Butter Pecan
Buttery roasted pecans drenched in genuine butter pecan ice cream
Gitchigoomie Bear Nuggets
Snowy white vanilla ice cream strewn with chocolate peanut butter Bear Nuggets and Mackinac thick fudge
Mamas Lickin Good
A party of "beater lickin' good" yellow cake batter ice cream and sweet blue frosting exploding with fireworks of candy confetti
Course cut coconut ice cream swirled with Mackinac thick fudge and loaded with dark chocolate flakes and roasted almonds.
Sweet strawberry ice cream crowned with plum juicy strawberries.
Dark chocolate ice cream swirled with Mackinac thick fudge and brimming with thick fudge-filled cups
Captain Jack Key Lime Pie
Amazing Key Lime Pie ice cream swirled with golden sweet graham crust
Rich chocolate ice cream at it's formal best
Thunder Bay Cherry
Mackinac Thick Fudge rumbling across black sweet cherries in rich vanilla ice cream
Cheesecake ice cream overflowing with raspberry ribbon and chock-full of chocolate chunks
Mack Jack Mint Fudge
Captain Jack's chocolate mint treasures and classic Mackinac Thick Fudge in rich mint ice cream
Pecan Turtle Fudge
Fresh Roasted pecans nestled in butter pecan ice cream rippling with Mackinac Classic Butter Pecan Fudge swirls and delicious chunks of Classic Butter Pecan Fudge
Black Forest Cherry
Delicious cherry ice cream teeming with plump, juicy, black sweet cherries
Grizzly Creek Choc Cashew
Rich dark chocolate ice cream swimming with roasted cashews and overflowing with Mackinac thick caramel.
Mouth-watering peanut butter ice cream swirled with our Mackinac chocolate cookie peanut butter variegate and loaded with yummy cookie dough pieces, delectable brownie bits, and scrumptious Mackinac Buckeyes
Caramel Mnt. Tracks
Caramel turtles climbing mountains of toffee ice cream flowing with streams of Mackinac Caramel Fudge and praline pecans
Mack Jack Cookie Dough
Tempting chunks of rich cookie dough and dark chocolate flakes flowing through swells of pure vanilla ice cream
Toffee ice cream with a silky smooth salty caramel ribbon, delicate blend of caramel turtles, and salty caramel truffles
Mackinac Original Fudge
Mackinac chewy fudge chunks in creamy vanilla ice cream, swirled with thick Mackinac Butter Fudge
Mighty Mac Peanut Butter Fudge
Mackinac Classic Fudge swirled through peanut butter ice cream, bursting with peanut butter Buckeyes and fudge cups